This interest session explores frameworks for fostering intentional creativity in music ministry that both speaks to and expands the congregation’s sense of their collective musical identity. These ideas encourage church musicians to embrace their congregation’s traditions while prompting them to consider in what ways those traditions can be celebrated and supplemented. While many music professionals rely on choral repertoire choice as the primary vehicle for creativity, this session highlights other avenues for creativity, including the use of ensembles and soloists, hymnody, summer scholarship programs that engage youth, and ideas for designing a concert series. This session addresses a wide range of ideas for all budgetary levels, and also speaks to the role of the organist/pianist in facilitating worship. Attendees of this session should leave the session with new ideas about how to approach programming in their music ministry as well as some concrete ideas to implement in their churches.